Sadra Medical Journal

Current Issue

By Issue

By Author

By Subject

Author Index

Keyword Index

About Journal

Aims and Scope

Editorial Board

Publication Ethics

Indexing and Abstracting

Related Links

Peer Review Process

Investigating the Theory of Correspondence between Pedanius Dioscorides and Luqman al-Hakim in Persian Medicine: An Evaluation of Verification Criteria

Document Type : Review Article

Authors

1 Department of History of Medicine, School of Persian Medicine,

2 Scientific Student Association of History of Medicine, Pharmacy and Veterinary, Students’ Scientific Research Center. Tehran University Medical Science, Tehran, Iran

3 Work done at History of Medicine, Independent Researcher, Tehran, Iran

4 Molecular Dermatology Research Center؛ Research Center for Traditional Medicine and History of Medicine, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran؛ Universal Scientific Education and Research Network (USERN), Tehran, Iran

10.30476/smsj.2025.104671.1579

Abstract

Some traditional medicine texts claim a connection between Pedanius Dioscorides and Luqman al-Hakim. The present study examined the feasibility of accepting this connection and the criteria for confirming or rejecting their correspondence using a documentary method. To this end, in addition to an analytical and historical assessment of the personalities of Luqman al-Hakim and Pedanius Dioscorides, their identities were traced and documented in key traditional Iranian medical texts, including Tohfat ol-Momenin, Gharabadin-e-Salehi, and Makhzan al-Adviyeh. The collected data were then examined, compared, and analyzed. Based on the findings, several historical and medical sources mentioned individuals named Dioscorides and Luqman, four of whom were prominent. The conflation of some reports about these four figures has led to confusion in their identification. The results indicated that the two figures, Dioscorides and Luqman al-Hakim, did not align chronologically. Tracing these individuals in the relevant sources revealed inconsistencies, particularly regarding their personal identities, such as their life span, place of birth or residence, or even their nationality, which casted doubt on the accuracy of the connection between them. Ultimately, it can be concluded that we are likely dealing with another individual who entered the Islamic era under the names Luqman and Dioscorides. Examining the personal identities mentioned in Persian medicine texts can thus enhance our understanding of historical medical records and their interpretation.

Keywords

References
  1. Mohammadifar S. Classification of Plants in De Materia Medica (al-Ḥashāʾish) of Dioscorides. Journal for the History of Science. 2015;13(2):213-36 [Persian].
  2. Ibn al-Baytar. De materia medica Interpretation. Beirut: Dar al-Gharb al-Islami; 1988. p. 13, 42-3 [Arabic].
  3. Al-Antaki D. Tadhkirat. Beirut: Alaalami; n.d. p. 22 [Arabic].
  4. Hussein MK. Al Mujaz Fi Tarikh al-Tibi wa alsaydala eind alearab. Vol 2. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2008. p. 283-4 [Arabic].
  5. Al Baba M. Arabic medical manuscripts in the National Library in Paris. Paris: Babylon Club; 2005. p. 218-24, 229-34, 244 [Arabic].
  6. Sezgin F. Arabic heritage history. Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance; 2001. p. 95-8, 230-1 [Arabic].
  7. Hakim Momin. Tohfa al-Mominin. Qom: Nor-e vahie; 2011. p. 66 [Persian].
  8. Salehi Heravi MS. Gharabadin- e- Salehi. Compiled by Abdolali Mohagheghzadeh, Parmis Badr, and Mohammad Reza Shamsardakani. Tehran: Choogan; 2013. p. 80-2, 192, 194-5 [Persian].
  9. Hakim Aqīlī Shirazi. Makhzan al-Adviyeh. Kolkata: n.p; 1844. p. 23 [Persian].
  10. Al-Akhawany Bukhārīy. Hidāyt al-Mutiʽllimin fi al-tib. Mashhad: Mashhad University of Medical Sciences: 1992. p. 641 [Persian].
  11. Hakim Jurjani. Zakhireye Khwarazmshahi. Vol 3. Qom: Ehyay-e- Teb Tabiee; 2006. p. 573, 87 [Persian].
  12. Rabban al-Tabari. The Firdaws al-ḥikma. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Elamiya; 2002. p. 35 [Arabic].
  13. Kitāb al-Ḥāwī fī al-ṭibb. Vol 2. Beirut: Dar Al Ehya Al Toras Al-Arabiya; 2001. p. 320 [Arabic].
  14. The Canon of Medicine. Vol 2. Beirut: Dar Al Ehya Al Toras Al-Arabiya; 2005. p. 48 [Arabic].
  15. Haly Abbas. Kitāb Kāmil aṣ-Ṣināʿa aṭ-Ṭibbiyya. Vol 3. Qom: Jalalaldin; 1968. p. 24 [Arabic].
  16. Kātib HazārahF. Tārīkh-i ḥukamā-yi mutaqaddimīn az hubūṭ-i Ḥaz̤rat Ādam tā bi-vujūd-i āmadan-i Ḥaz̤rat ʻĪsá. Kabul: Maṭbaʻ-i Vizārat-i Jalīlīyah-i Maʻārif; 1923. p. 1-2, 7-8, 15-16, 20-21, 52-53, 78-79, 92-93, 95-96, 108, 115-116, 129-130, 133, 136, 162-163, 172-173 [Persian].
  17. Ibn Juljul. Ṭabaqāt al-aṭibbā’ w’al-hukamā’. Cairo: Institut français d'archéologie orientale; 1955. p. 14, 15, 21-3 [Arabic].
  18. Al-Qifti. Ta'rikh al-Ḥukama (manuscript available in ketabdaneh-e Mad̲j̲les-e s̲h̲ūrā-ye mellī)); IR10-18607. p. 3-5, 9-10, 12, 14-15, 22, 25, 38, 56, 74-75, 110, 152, 208-210 [Persian].
  19. Ibn Matran. Bostan al-atiba'. Tehran: Society of Cultural Artifacts and Honors; 2007. p. 42 [Persian].
  20. Ibn Abī Uṣaybiʿ. Uyūn ul-Anbāʾ fī Ṭabaqāt al-Aṭibbā. Edited by Amer Najjar. Cairo: General Egyptian Book Organization; 2001. p. Vol 1. 157, 165, 196, 224-9, 231; Vol 3: 427 [Arabic].
  21. Touwaide A. Herbs and Healers from the Ancient Mediterranean through the Medieval West: Essays in Honor of John M. Riddle. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing; 2012. p. 10.
  22. Philosoph Al-Dawlah Tabrizi. Matrah- al-Anzar fi Trajeme Atebba' al Asar filsof va falasefeh al Amsar. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2004. p. 80, 262, 368-9 [Persian].
  23. Zubaydi M. Taj al aroos va the Javaher al-Qamoos. Edited by Ali Shiri. Beirut: Dar al-Fakr; 1993. p. Vol 2: 53; Vol 5: 232; Vol 14: 147 [Arabic].
  24. Najmabadi M. History of medicine in Iran. Tehran: University of Tehran; 1992. p. Vol 1: 69-71 [Persian].
  25. Al-Biruni. Al-Saydaneh. Translated by Baqer Muzaffarzadeh. Tehran: Academy of Persian Language and Literature; 2004. p. 75-9 [Persian].
  26. Universalis [Internet]. DIOSCORIDE PEDANIUS (40 env.-env. 90). Available from: https://www.universalis.fr/encyclopedie/dioscoride-pedanius/.
  27. Azdi A. Kitab- al ma'. Tehran: Research Institute for Islamic & Complementary Medicine (RICM); 2008. p. Vol 1: 321 [Arabic].
  28. Ibn Fatek. Mukhtār al-ḥikam wa-maḥāsin al-kalim. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2008. p. 329-32 [Arabic].
  29. Yusuf Heravi M. Bahr al-Jawahar. Qom: Jalal al-Din; 2008. p. 331 [Arabic].
  30. Golshani SA, Foroozani SAG, Jahan Kohan P, & Zohalinezhad ME. The Arabic medicine from the Birth of Islam’s prophet till the falling of Benny Umayyad Governments. History of Medicin Journal. 2016;4(10):95-129 [Persian].
  31. Salem Mukhtar. Altib Al-Islami bain Aleaqidat wa al'iibdae. Beirut: Al Maaref Foundation; 1987. p. 65-6 [Arabic].
  32. Hamawi S. Nour al-Uyoun and Jami` al-Funun. Riyadh: King Faisal Center for Research and Islamic Studies; 1986. p. 22-3, 659 [Arabic].
  33. Movahedi A. A study of the historical figure of Lughman Hakim. Quarterly of Faculty of Theology of Mashhad. 2001;53, 54:115-7 [Persian].
  34. Abu Ali Bal'ami. Tarikh-i Bal'ami. Translated by Mohammad-Taqi Bahar and Mohammad Parvin Gonabadi. Tehran: Zavarpublishment; 1974. p. 106, 109, 111, 525, 548, 552, 558-60 [Persian].
  35. Al-Shahrazuri. Nuzhat al-Arwaḥ wa-Rawḍat al-Afraḥ: fi Tarikh al-Hukama wa-al-Falasifah. Tehran: Elmifarhangipub; 2005. p. 309-14, 326 [Arabic].
  36. Al-Nishaburi. The Qiṣaṣ al-Anbiyāʾ. Edited by Habib Yaghmai. Tehran: Elmifarhangi; 2003. p. 29, 30, 264, 281, 333, 334, 339 [Persian].
  37. Habib al-siyar. Tehran: Khayam; 2001. p. Vol 1: 159 [Persian].
  38. Joseph Elian Sarkis. A dictionary of Arabic and Arabized publications. Egypt: Sarkis Press; 1928. p. Vol 2: 593 [Arabic].
  39. Ibn Manzur. Lisān al-ʿArab. Beirut: Dar al-Fakr; 1993. p. Vol: 547 [Arabic].
  40. Jawād Alī. Mufaṣṣal fī tārīkh al-'Arab qabla al-Islām. Beirut: Dar Al-Ilm lilmalayin; 1971. p. Vol 1: 317 [Arabic].
  41. Fakhreddin Tarehi. Majma-ul-Bahrain. n.p: n.d. p. Vol 6: 162-3 [Arabic].
  42. Diyarbakri HM. Tarikh Khamis. Beirut: Dar Al-Sad; 1558. p. Vol 1: 78 [Arabic].
  43. Qusouni M. Qamus al'Atibaa' wa Namous Alalbba. Damascus: Academy of the Arabic Language; 2000. p. Vol 2: 73-4, 123 [Arabic].
  44. Al-Maqdisi. Aḥsan al-Taqāsīm fī Maʿrifat al-Aqālīm. Translated by Alinaqi Monzavi. Tehran: Iranian authors and translators company; 1982. p. Vol 1: 217 [Persian].
  45. Hawkes JW. Persian Bible Dictionary. Tehran: Tahori Publications; 1970. p. 142 [Persian].
  46. Yaqut al-Hamawi. Kitāb Mu'jam al-Buldān (manuscript available in ketabdaneh-e Mad̲j̲les-e s̲h̲ūrā-ye mellī); 10-2416. p. 264, 267, 420 [Arabic].
  47. Yahya Frhat. Jame al'Aeshab wa Alnabatat. Beirut: Dar Al-Alamiah; 1993. p. 19-23 [Arabic].
  48. Khaja Piri M. Collection of medical Persian and Arabic manuscript microfilms available in Indian libraries. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2004. p. 23, 34, 203 [Persian].
  49. Mubasheri Tarazi N. List of Persian manuscripts in Egypt. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2008. p. Vol 2: 368-9, 600 [Persian].
  50. Esfahani M. Collection of Persian manuscripts of Central Asia and Caucasus in medical sciences. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2008. p. 14, 68, 40 [Persian].
  51. Ibn Abī Uṣaybiʿ. Uyūn ul-Anbāʾ fī Ṭabaqāt al-Aṭibbā. Translated by Seyyed Jafar Ghadban. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2007. p. 105-6 [Persian].
  52. Morteza Amely J. Aladab al tibiyat fi al'islam. Beirut: Dar Al-Balagha; 1991. p. 141, 163 [Arabic].
  53. Razavi A. Loqman Kakim. Jostar. 2003:1(4.5):46-58 [Persian].
  54. Mulla Sadra. Kasr al-Asnam al-Jahiliyyah. Tehran: Bonyad Hekmat Islami Sadra; 2002. p. 57-8, 65, 272, 278 [Arabic].
  55. Al-Umari. Masālik al-Abṣār fī Mamālik al-Amṣār. Abu Dhabi: Cultural Foundation; 2002. p. Vol 9: 19 [Arabic].
  56. Allameh Majlesi. Asman and Jahan, translation of Alsama' wa Alalam. Translated by Muhammad Baqir Kamarah'i. Tehran: Islamiya; 1972. p. Vol 1: 182 [Persian].
  57. Soltani A. Encyclopaedia of Traditional Medicine (Medicinal Plants). Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2004. p. Vol 2: 6-7 [Persian].
  58. Materia Medica. Translated by Ali Sharif Hosseini. Tehran: Iran University of Medical Sciences; 2004 [Persian].
  59. Mukhtar Hashem. Dioscorides and his book. Al-Turāṯ Al-arabī. 1984:4(13-14)150-63 [Arabic].
  60. Unknown author (6th century AH). Majamal al-Tawarikh wa Al-Qasas. Edited by Mohammad Taqi Bahar. Tehran: Kolaleh Khawar; n.d [Persian].
  61. Haji Khalifa. Taghvim al-Tawārīkh. Tehran: Mirasmaktoob; 2005 [Persian].
  62. Ibn al-Tilmidh. Maqālah fī al-faṣd. Aleppo: Higher Institute for the History of Arabic Science; 1996. p. 70 [Arabic].
  63. Min Mualafat ibn Sina Altibiya. Edited by Muhammad Zuhair Al Baba. Damascus: Higher Institute for the History of Arabic Science; 1983. p. Vol 1: 80-1 [Arabic].
  64. Ibn Juljul. Ṭabaqāt al-aṭibbā’ w’al-hukamā’. Translated by Seyyed Mohammad Kazem Imam. Tehran: University of Tehran; 1970. p. 70 [Persian].
Sadra Medical Journal
Volume 13, Issue 2
April 2025
Pages 409-420
Files
Share
How to cite
Statistics